The Success of the EU’s Petition to Ban Conversion Therapy Should Teach Us a Lesson

One year after its launch, a petition aimed at European citizens demanding a ban on conversion therapy has reached over one million signatures. Launched by the association ACT (Against Conversion Therapy), the initiative was launched with the objective of triggering a European legal procedure, allowing legislative proposals to be submitted to the European Union authorities by European citizens.

Protestors marching against conversion therapy.

Suport Donate GAY45

The petition has now met the eligibility requirements for European Citizens’ Initiatives, reformed in 2020 to improve accessibility. Meaning, the minimum threshold of signatories in at least seven EU member states has been reached, amounting to at least one million signatures in total. 

When online statements of support closed on May 17th, the relevant quota was reached in Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands, Slovenia, Spain, and Sweden – a total of 10 countries – amounting to over 1,200,000 signatures total. 

The Croatian signatories were also close to reaching the minimum quota, with 91.94% of the threshold reached, while France received the most signatures overall, with 663,596 statements of support. This represented over 1,000% of the required threshold in the country. The impressive number could be explained by the fact that the initiative originated in France, where conversion therapy is prohibited. A victory for LGBTQ+ people, the petition forces the European Commission to explore the citizens’ initiative, even if each signature must first be verified and validated.

A true tool of participatory democracy, this European Citizens’ Initiative could compel European administrations to establish regulations. It could also bring about sanctions against national authorities for non-compliance with the stated regulations in countries still ambivalent or hostile to LGBTQ+ rights, such as Poland, Romania, or Italy.

While the success of the petition is not a total victory and work still must be done, the ACT initiative allows for a united voice to be heard, to influence European policy, and to bring the issue back onto the agenda. The European Commissioner for Equality Hadja Lahbib has already implicitly lent support to the initiative, although without mentioning any legal means or position yet.

However, the support of influential figures in the EU administration and European politics, while highly desirable, should not detract from the fact that this result is primarily a result of citizen mobilisation. A citizen mobilisation which relied heavily on social media. 

In the case of France, the political class only belatedly relayed the initiative, which had already invaded social media for several days. Radical leftist group La France Insoumise representatives started to post about the initiative less than 48 hours before the initiative deadline, even later for the Socialists, whereas president Emmanuel Macron stated its support on the last day. If politicians and administrators are celebrating on social media, it shouldn’t be by writing a patronising “WE did it”, but rather by embracing the victory in itself. 

It is in fact important that such Citizen Initiatives, even more in such a context of a rising far-right, can be celebrated for what they are: a success of a citizen mobilisation, which does not rely solely on the political class, and which brings democracy to life by acting for its citizens rights. Acknowledging this is to buttress up our resistance and capacity of mobilisation. 

Besides, we also need to remember to pay attention to such political instrumentalisation, because it can be done by politicians who do not share the same stances. For instance, Aurore Bergé, a French liberal politician, is posting content celebrating the petition while she is known for engaging with transphobic ideas. Queer people will not guarantee their rights by compromising with a majority aiming to fragment us in groups and to discriminate against a new minority in order to perpetuate a norm. It is worth remembering that none of us are free until all of us are free.

 

GAY45 is committed to publishing a diversity of journalism, prose, and poetry. We’d like to hear your thoughts about this or any of our articles. And here’s our email if you want to send a letter: [email protected].

– – –

When we learn of a mistake, we acknowledge it with a correction. If you spot an error, please let us know.

– – –

Listen to our podcast ‘Gen Clash: Queer Perspectives on Current Affairs’ on your favourite podcast platform. 

– – –

We appreciate it. Thanks for reading.

 

Disclaimer:

This article does not necessarily reflect the opinions or views of GAY45 or its editorial staff. Please note that the content has not undergone an exhaustive fact-checking process by our editorial team. While we strive for accuracy and quality in our publications, responsibility for the opinions, claims, and accuracy of this article lies solely with the author(s) or contributor(s).

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate the content presented and seek additional sources or verification when necessary. We value diverse perspectives and promote open discourse on various subjects, but it is essential to recognise that individual articles may not represent the official stance or rigorous fact-checking standards of our publication.

For any inquiries or concerns about the content of this article, please contact the author(s) directly or reach out to our editorial team using the provided contact information. Your feedback is valuable to us as we strive to deliver a wide range of perspectives and information to our readers.

GAY45 journalists are not permitted to endorse or campaign for candidates or political causes. This includes participating in rallies or donating money to a candidate or cause.

Author

  • Arthur Cormerais is junior Political Editor at GAY45. From France, he is currently based in Warsaw. He is also a cinema fan who identifies as queer. He likes to tackle politics, social marginalisation, and the medium of cinema.

    View all posts
Did we mention we accept donations? Indeed, love.

If this story matters to you, help us tell the next one — donate what you can today.

Support GAY45
Follow on Feedly